Streaming Video Ideas And Methods For Video Producers – Taming The Video Compression Monster

This text is particularly aimed toward video producers who’re all for getting probably the most out of their streaming video productions by way of video and audio high quality. It primarily entails one of the best working practices for making certain that your streaming video wrestles nicely with that dastardly beast, the “compression monster”, which desires to show all of your pristine video to digital mush.

I got here from a background in skilled video and media manufacturing in Perth, Western Australia, taking pictures TV commercials, unbiased movie, company video, and far rather more. With the arrival of the web, I grew to become enthusiastic about the opportunity of utilizing it as a manner of delivering high quality streaming video promoting for companies each in Perth and all over the world. So I based my present enterprise, ONLINE AURA, and went into creating video particularly tailor-made for streaming. The issue was, though I used to be conversant in the speculation of video compression, probably the most I would ever come up towards this beast was on the stage of VHS or DVD manufacturing, the place it often wrangled however by no means inflicted critical injury upon me. The fact of video streaming compression was an enormous adjustment nonetheless, as I watched pin sharp photographs shredded into digital mud earlier than my eyes, and heard wonderful hovering music changed into a horrific sequence of farts and dying bumblebees.

Over the course of time, by way of expertise of testing and producing many streaming movies for native shoppers, I learnt one of the best practices and methods for taking pictures and enhancing streaming video. I will not say I’ve tamed the compression monster, as a result of he nonetheless lurks over my shoulder on each shoot, however I’ll say that I’ve learnt find out how to hold him below management and make it by way of the video compression course of with just some scratches right here and there. So this articles consists of plenty of ideas and guides that can assist you battle this beast in your subsequent streaming video manufacturing.


1. Let there be Gentle – I will begin with the obvious and what may be thought of as some of the essential points in producing high quality video streaming. I do know there’s quite a lot of issues written about this recommending strongly-lit flat lighting (i.e – no shadows). The speculation being that lowering distinction in your picture means that it’s going to compress extra effectively and you may find yourself with the next high quality streaming picture. This is not fairly proper, because the human notion of “sharpness” depends on distinction variations, and despite the fact that the next distinction picture could in mathematical phrases be much less nicely compressed at a pixel by pixel stage, it’ll create the phantasm of being sharper to the viewer. Mainly the rule for highest quality is to supply a clean ratio of distinction, and to favor massive mushy sources that do not over mild what you are attempting to shoot. Blasting mild instantly out of your digital camera place over all the scene shouldn’t be going to supply favorable outcomes by way of streaming video high quality. The very best outcomes come from mushy directional sources, however there’s additionally room for backlighting and different artistic approaches.

You must make allowances for the eventual compression, however that typically means conserving your picture distinction inside a suitable ratio. Low mild is clearly an issue, and night time taking pictures may be troublesome. Any grain goes to play havoc and awake the previous compression monster, who will hungrily eat up each little vibrating pixel. You need to use grain eradicating plug-ins, however they will have the impact of softening your picture and can compress generally even worse. Crushing your black ranges fully can generally assist, and de-saturating your picture and adjusting midtones will also be helpful. If you must shoot in low-light on the road, attempt not too utilizing the achieve controls in your digital camera, and as an alternative go for a low shutter (in case your digital camera has it). Decrease shutter speeds will typically compress higher. For interview topics within the studio, I typically use a mushy key and a little bit of a kicker or backlight, with just a bit little bit of frontal fill. For video compression I make certain the background is comparatively static and defocused. Utilizing inexperienced display screen and changing the background with a blurred nonetheless picture or slowly shifting blurred background works nicely, and conserving background colours muted helps compression.

2. Digital camera motion – Clearly quite a lot of quick digital camera motion goes to require increased charges of compression for streaming video. However several types of motion even have totally different results. A clean dolly shot will truly compress moderately nicely however, apparently sufficient, the identical move-in or out utilizing a zoom as an alternative won’t compress nicely, and usually zooms are to be prevented if potential. Hand-held photographs will are likely to undergo tremendously, except they’re stabilized later utilizing a software program plug-in resembling Steadymove. Steadicam pictures can work moderately nicely if executed nicely. Sadly most steadicam pictures comprise a little bit of ‘float’ which, though barely perceptible to the common viewer, won’t compress in addition to a real dolly or monitor shot. Locked off pictures will clearly compress finest, although it’s depending on what’s in entrance of the digital camera!

3. Movement in entrance – Sure issues compress nicely, whereas sure different issues compress poorly. Water and waves look stunning and crystalline on DVD, however within the streaming video world they fall to items. They carry took a lot randomly shifting wonderful element. The identical with leaves blowing on a tree within the wind. Should you’re taking pictures an interview or spot with somebody in entrance of a tree with wonderful leaves on a windy day, you must contemplate shifting them to soak up a background with much less movement. Clearly you need to have issues shifting in your digital camera body to supply curiosity (that is the entire level of getting video over a slide present), however take into consideration how a lot of the body is shifting. Should you can isolate your shifting topic with an extended lens and have the background blur out, that can compress higher and in addition seem sharper to your viewer. Due to the small display screen dimension, when taking pictures folks transfer in a bit tighter. Shut ups may be only.

4. VBR and the artwork of “compression accounting” – It’s best to know that utilizing Variable Bit Charge in your video will present a big high quality increase for many movies over commonplace CBR (fixed bit fee). However to maximise the standard of your streaming video it’s possible you’ll must reap the benefits of this variable bit fee capability by doing what I discuss with as compression accounting.

What’s that? Think about I’ve a finances of $250 per day for a month to purchase no matter goodies I would like. In a strict CBR world I get $250 firstly of the primary day, and, no matter whether or not I spent the whole thing or not, it might return to zero on the finish. The second day I would get $250 once more and so forth. So, in CBR world, I’ll as nicely spend all of my $250, as a result of there is not any saving for the subsequent day. If I see a $800 guitar within the window, I can not purchase it, as a result of I will by no means have that a lot cash, and I’ve to accept a poorer high quality $200 one as an alternative. In VBR world nonetheless, there’s saving. If I do not spend my $250 on the primary day, and as an alternative spend $150, which means I can spend the $100 I saved another time. In impact, I can limit my spending within the current so I can purchase that $800 guitar sooner or later with the cash I saved. Should you’ve uncovered the which means in my torturous analogy, what this implies is that this – when taking pictures in VBR mode I’ve received an concept of what number of knowledge bits I’ve received to play with and I can unfold them out accordingly. Realizing that I need to shoot one thing with quite a lot of digital camera motion, like a dynamic steadicam shot by way of a crowd of shifting folks, I do know that I ought to stability that out with a few locked off pictures with little or no motion. It is the equal of spending $800 on that guitar (the steadicam shot), by scrimping on different days (i.e. taking pictures the lock-offs). Relating to encoding, the encoder will have a look at the video on the primary go, be aware the quantity of motion in every shot and work out a mean stage of compression for every shot given the whole common it has to play with. The steadicam shot may take 800kbps whereas the lock-off pictures solely take 80-100kbps. So the trick is balancing out the variety of advanced and easy pictures to take finest benefit of VBR compression. Optimistically you will have a great stability and find yourself with a lot better use of compression to provide you a greater high quality streaming video.

5. Shoot progressive – Taking pictures for streaming video signifies that you are producing for a pc display screen, which is often an LCD. The best way pc course of shifting photographs is basically totally different out of your typical TV. I may write three thousand phrases in regards to the technical variations, however principally the conclusion is that progressive scanned or de-interlaced video completely matches the best way a pc monitor shows these photographs. Interlaced video (which accommodates fields) shows movement completely nicely on televisions, however will historically not encode movement nicely with streaming video, creating movement artifacts and occasional streaking results. The best choice is to shoot with a digital camera that delivers photographs in progressive scan mode. Whereas there are high-end skilled cameras, most client fashions will not. Nonetheless the prosumer fashions produced by Canon, particularly the XL-1, XL-2 and XM2, all function a ‘body’ mode that make these cameras adapt nicely to streaming video. Failing that, movies needs to be de-interlaced both on the enhancing stage utilizing software program (e.g Premiere Professional, Avid), or on the encoding stage. High quality encoders resembling Canopus procoder usually provide de-interlaced supply.


1. Classical cuts – The compression issue of streaming video signifies that a classical taking pictures model produces higher outcomes than MTV model camerawork. And the identical factor applies to enhancing. Though enhancing nonetheless needs to be fairly snappy to suit inside the time format, there aren’t the flowery flash frames and transitions you’ll usually favor when taking pictures for TV or DVD supply. One of many nice sacrifices I truly felt within the early days of manufacturing streaming video ads was after I needed to lose the straightforward cross-dissolve. Cross-dissolves are some of the generally used transitions between pictures and earlier than I began to supply streaming video for the net I used them often. Sadly cross-dissolves do not compress nicely, and for those who watch streaming movies fastidiously you’ll discover in the course of the dissolve from one shot to the subsequent there are quite a lot of artifacts – a positive signal that the transition impact is gobbling up worthwhile compression {dollars}! A straight reduce is solely probably the most environment friendly solution to go, and for those who check out virtually all of the streaming video examples featured on my web site, you will see that each single transition is a straight reduce. Which may appear limiting, however after some time of doing movies like that, you will be taught to make use of that methodology of enhancing, and unusually sufficient it will additionally assist you assemble sequences higher. It might appear unusual to some with high-end video enhancing software program with actually tons of of obtainable transitions, however you will truly start to understand the artwork of enhancing extra while you’re in a position to create a rhythm and move from straight slicing.

2. Grade your picture for LCD and compression – One other distinction between commonplace TVs and pc LCDs are the best way they course of color. When grading for streaming video supply you’ve fairly a little bit of latitude for “souping-up” the color, as they may usually show extra color saturation that the majority televisions. Grading photographs is one other key to creating positive your last streaming video appears to be like its finest on-line. Beefing up distinction utilizing ranges filters or unsharp masks filters is one other manner of making the notion of a sharper video picture, and counteracts each the softening impact of LCD shows in addition to the considerably washed out impact produced by some encoders in the course of the video compression course of. Bear in mind there are trade-offs to overdoing it with the color although – it takes extra compression to course of these saturated colors. Should you’re after maximium sharpness at low bit-rates, you must truly contemplate de-saturating the color or going all the best way and having it in B&W or monochrome.

3. Totally different points – One factor you may very well reap the benefits of creatively as a producer of streaming movies is you can create streaming movies with just about any facet ratio you want. From ultra-widescreen to vertical skyscraper codecs, you are not restricted by the facet ratio of your TV or digital camera. This has partly to do with the truth that, while you’re producing video streaming adverts, your display screen dimension or dimensions are smaller that your initially captured picture. So every kind of cropping results can happen. This may be helpful additionally when producing movies which are a part of banners, alongside different graphics. In case your enhancing software program helps totally different facet ratios, experiment with this, or if it would not, you may all the time crop later in an encoding program. Chances are you’ll even select to edit in a compositing program like Adobe After Results, which allows you any display screen dimension and facet ratio you want.

4. Totally different speeds – One factor that may compress nicely is gradual movement. The distinction between successive frames is often small and so it compresses moderately nicely. I exploit a particular frame-blender to supply very clean gradual movement video results and scale back the choppiness of video gradual movement. One other factor I find yourself doing generally in regard to movement is utilizing fast quick ramps (quick movement) inside pictures. This may eat up knowledge, as you finish of with quite a lot of distinction between successive frames, nevertheless it does give movies loads of vitality, and if the ramp is fast the injury may be minimal. Including a keyframed blur inside the ramp can work to attenuate this for those who’re doing a whip-pan transfer as nicely.

4. Audio – Audio high quality is simply as essential as video. Should you skimp on audio, it will deliver down the entire stage of your manufacturing. Should you’re using voice-over, make certain your expertise speaks clearly and try to EQ them tight, which generally means backing off bass frequencies and making a punchy center. Music can also be essential. For many who have to make use of generic or inventory music, try to favor easy preparations and again off the cheese issue. Preparations with quick punchy sounds, like percussive devices, compress higher than lengthy dense sounds, like a string orchestra. All of it will depend on the way you encode this in fact. Within the early days, as a way to maximize the video bit fee, I would use very low audio charges. Utilizing home windows media encoding, I would use their “voice codec” at 20kbps mono. In case your mixture of voice and music is sharp and punchy, it’d maintain up moderately nicely, so long as the music did not function quite a lot of dense sustained notes. As extra folks have gotten quicker connections, I’ve upped the bit fee and now have a tendency to make use of 32kbps stereo (albeit at a decrease pattern fee) or generally increased. A superb mono sound is preferable to a stereo sound that is breaking apart because of compression, so watch out. The one wonderful thing about utilizing Home windows media, versus Flash, is you can produce good high quality audio at very low bit-rates, as a result of the home windows audio codec is remarkably good and much superior to mp3. If you must encode in Flash, try to see what codec is getting used in your audio. The very best mp3 codec broadly in use is the LAME codec.

5. Supply Codecs – Once I began, there have been actually Three main codecs for streaming that I felt had been an possibility: Home windows media, Realplayer and Quicktime. Numerous testing went into it, and principally it got here down between Home windows media and Realplayer. On the time I felt Realplayer supplied barely higher high quality and higher color saturation, although due to the widespread use of home windows media participant (because of the monopolizing of Gates’ Microsoft), Home windows media was my most well-liked supply format. For me, Actual and Quicktime have principally fallen off the radar by way of streaming video. Now it is down to 2 choices – Home windows media and Flash 8. Flash was by no means actually environment friendly sufficient earlier than to supply a real various to the others, however with the widespread acceptance of the Flash format for video and the advance of Flash video with the brand new On2 codec, it’s a actual possibility. The convenience during which it is ready to combine into webpages, in addition to Flash-created information, makes it very tempting. It nonetheless would not provide the general effectivity of Home windows, which at a compression stage for video and audio nonetheless wins out. You will have to decide on your self what’s finest in your streaming video supply format.

Additionally, after I began, I used to be doing solely actual streaming, that’s, clever multi-bitrate streaming utilizing a Home windows streaming server. I launched nonetheless that, if I wished to supply very top quality content material at affordable bit charges, then streaming wasn’t fairly going to do it for me. That is why progressive obtain, with its 2-pass VBR, principally gained me over as a manner of delivering quick (usually 2minutes or much less) video ads on-line. I will use clever streaming for different issues which require low bit-rates, resembling audio and nonetheless sequences, however that is about all.

I hope this has given you a couple of concepts about finest working practices for producing streaming movies, whether or not they be for internet marketing, video blogs or no matter. Video streaming carries with it a selected set of labor practices that set it aside from the manufacturing calls for of different media, like DVD. Having an concept of these components earlier than you go right into a streaming video manufacturing will maintain you in good stead, and assist you to supply a a lot better finish consequence.

Thanks for studying, and I hope to meet up with you someday down the monitor with extra articles. You’ll be able to go to my web site at [] or e-mail me with questions.

Supply by Micheal Fletcher-Jones

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *